Republic Republic Republic
  • Log in
Oops! We couldn’t find any results...
Can’t find a deal? Try advanced search.
Is something missing? Add your suggestion here.
Primary market Live deals Secondary market Buy and sell Republic Note Own a piece of Republic's upside Investor Network Membership Receive exclusive discounts and benefits
Republic Venture Opportunities for accredited investors
Republic Capital Multi-stage venture firm Republic Digital Crypto hedge fund
Wallet Manage your digital assets Mobile app Available on iOS or Android Learning center Explore investor resources FAQ Get your questions answered
Capital fundraising Raise on Republic Tokenized assets Design, launch, manage tokenized assets Sharedrops Gift equity as a reward
Advisory Access veteran web3 advisors Infrastructure Stake your digital assets Tokenization Deploy your assets on-chain Asset management Explore digital asset funds
Republic Capital In-house Venture Capital fund Broker dealer Regulated capital services
Log in Sign up

Republic Republic Republic
Oops! We couldn’t find any results...
Can’t find a deal? Try advanced search.
Is something missing? Add your suggestion here.
  • US
  • Log in
  • Sign up
All investors
Primary market Live deals Secondary market Buy and sell Republic Note Own a piece of Republic's upside Investor Network Membership Receive exclusive discounts and benefits
Accredited only
Republic Venture Opportunities for accredited investors
Institutional
Republic Capital Multi-stage venture firm Republic Digital Crypto hedge fund
More
Wallet Manage your digital assets Mobile app Available on iOS or Android Learning center Explore investor resources FAQ Get your questions answered
Spotlight deal
ASM Capital Whiskey Fund
ASM Capital Whiskey Fund
Funding the emergence of American Single Malt
Growth capital solutions
Capital fundraising Raise on Republic Tokenized assets Design, launch, manage tokenized assets
Sharedrops Gift equity as a reward
Web3 services
Advisory Access veteran web3 advisors Infrastructure Stake your digital assets Tokenization Deploy your assets on-chain Asset management Explore digital asset funds
Institutional services
Republic Capital In-house Venture Capital fund
Broker dealer Regulated capital services
Journal

Ask me anything

· May 13, 2020

AMA: Dustin Shay — Impact with intention

  • Liked
    Like
    2
  • Comments (4)

Hey y’all, I’m Dustin Shay. I’m excited to hear (and attempt to answer) your questions during this week’s AMA. 

I work to break down barriers keeping entrepreneurship from making impact on issues that matter. Less than 15% of companies on the unicorn list are solving issues of access, agency, and quality in healthcare, education, housing, food/agriculture, or energy. Less than 15% of support goes to women-led ventures and less than 2% to black or LatinX founders in the US. Less than 25% of US VC goes outside of NY, CA, and MA. 

The most successful entrepreneurs solve problems they know. Problems they’ve lived. And the biggest gaps in our society disproportionately affect women, people of color, and people outside of major cities. But the entrepreneurs from these communities often lack access to networks, guidance, and capital that they need to scale their solutions up. 

It’s not that these founders lack drive or that the companies they’re leading aren’t good investments. It’s not that VCs are individually and intentionally overallocating their capital to a few people and places. There’s a combination of systemic barriers, implicit and explicit biases, and outdated approaches that keep society from unlocking the power of entrepreneurship.

In my day job, I help to lead Village Capital, the world’s most active and connected seed-stage impact investing organization. For the last 10 years, we’ve led inclusive accelerator programs all around the world, taking a data-driven approach to finding the right way to support early-stage startups - and creating a process proven to help ventures raise 3x more capital, generate 2x more revenue, and growth their companies 50% faster than a control group. We’ve proven a different kind of investment model, entrepreneur peer selection, can mitigate bias and create a more inclusive portfolio while outperforming funds of its venture year. We’re using this experience to build the infrastructure of a better system - helping accelerators work better, helping investors and entrepreneurs connect, and sharing open resources for founders everywhere.

I lead our Partnerships team now, securing funding and strategic partnerships with industry-leading corporations, institutional foundations, and inspired individual investors and philanthropists. Before this, I led several of our accelerator programs, including Village Capital’s first accelerator program focused on supporting financial health-focused ventures in 2014. That practice alone has now helped over 250 founders worldwide go on to raise over $1B and reach hundreds of thousands of people and small businesses with services that improve their economic mobility and financial resiliency.

Outside of VilCap, I’m an advisory board member of Left Tackle Capital, which is changing the demographics of VC. Right now, 92% of investment teams in early-stage VC are white men, and ~90% of investment goes to white men. We believe a more representative investment community leads to more equitable, resilient, and successful portfolios. We help first- and second-time fund managers who are women or PoC access the capital, community, and tools they need to launch their investment funds. We’re in the inaugural class right now, working with 12 amazing funds.

I work with Republic to help founders that the traditional VC leaves out find other paths to get the capital they need to scale. I’m specifically looking for companies that are solving systemic issues in economic empowerment, the future of work, or sustainability that are led by women or people of color.

Before all of this, I led investment teams with the Sorenson Impact Center, which made seed-stage investments in startups improving livelihoods worldwide. Before that, I was a barista and a student, and spent eight years slinging coffee at local coffeehouses and international chains.

I’m a nerd that enjoys video and board games, genuine conversations with people that are smarter than me, and cooking delicious (but ugly) food. I yell at podcasts about politics and spend far too much time inconsistently studying Japanese (I can hold simple conversations), trying to learn guitar (I’m terrible at it), watching stupid cartoon shows, or playing D&D.

You can ask me about anything. How to approach investors or strategic partners, what allyship means in the entrepreneurial and investment communities, what better accelerator programs look like, why the system needs to change, or what effects social distancing has on group dynamics in roleplaying games. 

Let’s get started!


Republic Venture Partner AMA (Ask Me Anything) is a weekly series. Feel free to ask questions in the discussion section below.* He will be answering questions Wednesday 5/13 through Friday 5/15 so submit your questions now!

*must sign into Republic account to ask questions — register here first!


This educational article is provided by Republic to help its users understand this area of the market, it should not be construed as investment advice as it is impersonal, disinterested and was produced by Republic for Republic’s users, without remuneration received or expected.

Share this story

4 comments

Share feedback and comment below. Please note that this section is not monitored by Republic. If you have any questions please reach out to investors@republic.co

The comment you're trying to see no longer exists.

Profile picture of Cheryl Campos
Cheryl Campos
5 years ago
From @kdoesvc on our @joinrepublic Instagram: "What are the best ways to bridge the business & policy divide?"
3 likes Reply
Profile picture of Dustin Shay
Dustin Shay @cheryl-campos @kdoesvc has an interesting question. There are a ton of divides between business and policy, but most of them center around a straight up lack of entrepreneur perspective in the halls of Congress. It's shocking how little our senators and representatives are able to speak with actual business owners. Sure, they may hear from multi-million/-billion dollar organizations that can buy time, but early-stage startups, Main Street businesses, and single proprietors have almost no time to speak with their representatives in the government about the policies that impact their businesses the most. Each year, the Kauffman Foundation leads a "State of Entrepreneurship" mission to DC to speak more about the issues, gathering an incredible and exciting number of think tanks, local VCs, and NGOs to talk about the issues and bring them up to our lawmakers. Last year, the Village Capital team made sure that Clarence Bethea, founder of Upsie and a Village Capital program graduate, joined the trip to the Hill. Clarence has a growing, VC-backed business and, as an African American founder in the Twin Cities area, has a perspective that is very different from the typical coastal techbro. For the representatives that made the time to join the events the Kauffman Foundation put on, there was one phrase we heard repeated over and over, "This is the first time I've actually had the chance to meet an entrepreneur." It's shocking, but it's true. The best way to bridge the business and policy divide is to get entrepreneurs (not, and I can't stress this enough, NOT major industry leaders) onto the Hill and speaking with lawmakers.
5 years ago
0 Like
·
Reply
·
5 years ago
Profile picture of Ms Stacey L Bracey
Ms Stacey L Bracey
5 years ago
Where can someone get VC101 info to learn about VC and how they work?
Where can someone go to learn about VC for their businesses?
How does one prepare a presentation for a VC?
What instructions would you give someone who is just learning about VC?
2 likes Reply
Profile picture of Dustin Shay
Dustin Shay @ms-stacey-l-bracey Great questions!

Response 1/2

Where can someone get VC101 info to learn about VC and how they work?
All VCs are different. Period. If someone says they can tell you everything, they're lying. But there are some good resources for the basics - like whether a business is a good fit for equity-based investment at all (which is what most VCs deploy), common questions that VCs ask, etc. Here's a good blog post that should serve as a really, really beginner's style intro: startupsventurecapital.com/venture-capital-101-a-crash-course-ed80b0d87bd5

Where can someone go to learn about VC for their businesses?
I'm assuming you're asking about how to find out which VCs are a good fit/likely to invest. The VC industry/space is wildly exclusive and famously opaque. The vast majority of deals are done "in network" and you'll see this stated explicitly on some VC funds' websites. There's literally zero accountability in this space, so VCs do whatever they want, mostly. That said, there are groups that are trying to make this a more navigable space. Village Capital, for example, has built Abaca (abaca.app). If you fill out the short evaluation, it will use that information to try to match you up to VCs (and also give you tips on how to present your business!).
5 years ago
1 like
·
Reply
·
5 years ago
Profile picture of Dustin Shay
Dustin Shay @ms-stacey-l-bracey Response 2/2

How does one prepare a presentation for a VC?
There are whole schools and programs and courses dedicated to this, but the core things that VCs want to understand are your value proposition (what problem are you solving and how), your model (how do you make money), your special sauce (how are you doing this differently/in a way no one else can), and your market (who are you solving the problem for and how much money they have to spent on that solution). Explain it like you're explaining it to a five year old. VCs don't want to think about it too hard until they're going through real diligence. Check out this collection of decks if you're interested: alexanderjarvis.com/pitch-deck-collection-from-vc-funded-startups

What instructions would you give someone who is just learning about VC?
Take the Venture Deals course from Brad Feld. It's free. It's well organized. It's really, really valuable. feld.com/archives/2020/02/venture-deals-online-course-spring-2020-registration-is-open.html
5 years ago
1 like
·
Reply
·
5 years ago
Profile picture of Ms Stacey L Bracey
Ms Stacey L Bracey @dustin-shay Thank you very much for your time and thorough responses. Enjoy your evening.
5 years ago
1 like
·
Reply
·
5 years ago
Profile picture of Alex Knighton
Alex Knighton
5 years ago
What hurdles exist in getting more complete data to generate ESG scores and measure impact?
2 likes Reply
Profile picture of Dustin Shay
Dustin Shay @alex-knighton That's a great question, and I think it gets at the heart of what's limiting impact investing today.

There are a couple of answers on that front:
1. No one knows what impact means. Or, at least, no one can agree on it. For some investors, impact is negative screens. For others, only positive, measurable change on specific issues counts. For some, if you run an extractive, resource-based business but treat your employees well, that's totally fine. There are some metrics libraries out there (GIIRS, IRIS, etc) but none of them are being seen as the standard. Until we have a clear definition, we won't be able to create scores that measure impact on a case-by-case basis, let alone a blanket, 0-100 ESG score.

2. Measuring impact is hard, and not consistently rewarded. Imagine if someone gave you a one-time payment of $500 to pick up trash, but asked that every time you picked up trash that you saw on the street and threw it away, you also had to report on how much you threw away, what kind of trash it was, and where you did it. You'd NEVER do that report (or maybe you would, but not forever). It's the same problem for startups (and, at a totally different scale, for public companies). Not only is impact onerous to measure, it's not rewarded over time.

3. It's never enough. I call this the Starbucks Problem. Everyone sees a video about a turtle with a straw up its nose, and Starbucks says, "That's awful. Okay. No more plastic straws." Immediately, consumers and media say, "Wow, way to go Starbucks, what about the rest of your products? You think this is enough?" and Starbucks has a really mixed PR result. Meanwhile, McDonald's and every other fast food place do nothing, spend nothing, and see no change in the public's perception of their company.

In short, measuring impact is subjective, difficult, expensive, and not typically rewarded financially or increased public good will... But that doesn't mean we shouldn't try to address those barriers.
5 years ago
2 likes
·
Reply
·
5 years ago
Profile picture of Jacob Severn
Jacob Severn
5 years ago
Is financialization a good tool to get people to care about hard to fund projects like core infrastructure and basic science research?
2 likes Reply
Profile picture of Dustin Shay
Dustin Shay @jake-severn I think that's an interesting question and there are a million and one answers to it. I think the short answer is 'only in moderation.'

Completely financializing core infrastructure is a recipe for an unequal society. We can see what happens when hospitals and healthcare are privatized by looking at what's happening now: they're losing billions, in some cases shutting down, and leaving people without care (nytimes.com/2020/05/15/us/hospitals-revenue-coronavirus.html?action=click&module=Top%20Stories&pgtype=Homepage). You can also see it in private toll roads. Right now, it's an inconvenience, but if all roads were private toll roads, people on the lower end of the economic spectrum would be unable to travel because they can't pay the fee. It's like that old quote of having to pay to leave your apartment.

By the same token, basic scientific research, if financialized, looks a lot like pharmaceutical research does now: unless the market is big enough, there's no reason to actually go out and conduct research. Some of the biggest accomplishments of our society, things that paved the way for the modern era like space exploration, wouldn't be profitable, wouldn't get funded, and wouldn't happen.

What I believe is that there's a role for business in mitigating big, intractable challenges that are too big or unwieldy for philanthropy, and that lack sufficient political will for government intervention. We shouldn't overweight it, and it shouldn't be applied in all circumstances, but there is definitely a role for it right now.
5 years ago
3 likes
·
Reply
·
5 years ago
Profile picture of Jacob Severn
Jacob Severn @dustin-shay Thank you for your thoughtful answer! I agree with your analysis. Interesting problem set, trying to figure out how to incentivize our community to invest in itself
5 years ago
2 likes
·
Reply
·
5 years ago

Get notified about new posts

Not a valid email address
Republic

Giving everyone access to early-stage startup investing

For investors
  • Why invest
  • How it works
  • FAQ
  • Risks
  • Privacy policy
  • Accessibility
  • Cookie Preferences
  • Form CRS
For startups
  • Why raise
  • Learn
  • FAQ
  • Instruments
  • Crowd SAFE
  • Tokenized assets
Company
  • About
  • Journal
  • Events
  • Contact
  • We're hiring!
Dollar Refer a startup, get $2,500
Dollar Refer a startup, get $2,500

Invest in the app

Android app iOS app

Invest in the app

Android app iOS app

This site (the "Site") is owned and maintained by OpenDeal Inc., which is not a registered broker-dealer. OpenDeal Inc. does not give investment advice, endorsement, analysis or recommendations with respect to any securities. All securities listed here are being offered by, and all information included on this Site is the responsibility of, the applicable issuer of such securities. The intermediary facilitating the offering will be identified in such offering’s documentation.

All related securities activity is conducted by OpenDeal Broker LLC a registered broker-dealer, Member of FINRA and SiPC, an affiliate of OpenDeal Inc. and OpenDeal Portal LLC, located at 149 5th Avenue, 10th Floor, New York, NY 10010. Please check our background on FINRA’s BrokerCheck.

Certain pages discussing the mechanics and providing educational materials regarding regulation crowdfunding offerings may refer to OpenDeal Broker LLC and OpenDeal Portal LLC collectively as “Republic”, solely for explanatory purposes.

Neither OpenDeal Inc., OpenDeal Portal LLC nor OpenDeal Broker LLC make investment recommendations and no communication, through this Site, or in any other medium, should be construed as a recommendation for any security offered on or off this investment platform. Investment opportunities posted on this Site are private placements of securities that are not publicly traded, involve a high degree of risk, may lose value including the total loss of invested capital, are subject to holding period requirements and are intended for investors who do not need a liquid investment. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Investors must be able to afford the loss of their entire investment. Only qualified investors, who understand the risks of early-stage investment and who meet the Republic's investment criteria may invest. Investors may be restricted to only Accredited Investors or non-U.S. persons, to invest in offerings hosted by OpenDeal Broker. Neither OpenDeal Inc., OpenDeal Portal LLC nor OpenDeal Broker LLC, nor any of their officers, directors, agents and employees make any warranty, express or implied, of any kind whatsoever related to the adequacy, accuracy or completeness of any information on this Site or the use of information on this site. Offers to sell securities can only be made through official offering documents that contain important information about the investment and the issuers, including risks. Investors should carefully read the offering documents. Investors should conduct their own due diligence and are encouraged to consult with their tax, legal and financial advisors.

By accessing the Site and any pages thereof, you agree to be bound by the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Please also see OpenDeal Broker’s Business Continuity Plan and Additional Risk Disclosures. All issuers offering securities under regulation crowdfunding as hosted by OpenDeal Portal LLC are listed on the All Companies Page. The inclusion or exclusion of an issuer on the Platform Page and/or Republic’s Homepage, which includes offerings conducted under regulation crowdfunding as well as other exemptions from registration, is not based upon any endorsement or recommendation by OpenDeal Inc, OpenDeal Portal LLC, or OpenDeal Broker LLC, nor any of their affiliates, officers, directors, agents, and employees. Rather, issuers of securities may, in their sole discretion, opt-out of being listed on the Platform Page and Homepage.

Investors should verify any issuer information they consider important before making an investment.

Investments in private companies are particularly risky and may result in total loss of invested capital. Past performance of a security or a company does not guarantee future results or returns. Only investors who understand the risks of early stage investment and who meet the Republic's investment criteria may invest.

Neither OpenDeal Inc., OpenDeal Portal LLC nor OpenDeal Broker LLC verify information provided by companies on this Site and makes no assurance as to the completeness or accuracy of any such information. Additional information about companies fundraising on the Site can be found by searching the EDGAR database, or the offering documentation located on the Site when the offering does not require an EDGAR filing.

To help the government fight the funding of terrorism and money laundering activities, Federal law requires all financial institutions to obtain, verify, and record information that identifies each person who opens an account. Therefore, when you use the Services we will ask for your name, address, date of birth, and other information that will allow us to identify you. We may also ask to see your driver's license, passport or other identifying documents.

Republic and its affiliates are not and do not operate or act as a bank. Certain banking services are provided by BankProv, member FDIC / member DIF. FDIC coverage only applies in the event of bank failure. Digital (crypto) assets and investment products are not insured by the FDIC, may lose value, and are not deposits or other obligations of BankProv and are not guaranteed by BankProv. Terms and conditions apply.

Invest in startups using your credit card
You can invest using your credit card

Made in SF/NYC